Loading article content...
Loading article content...
“A system that has lost the capacity to give hope is not simply inefficient. It is dangerous for the country.” Musharaf Abdullahi Rashid
When an ordinary person suffers from an illness, the natural expectation is that he will search for a solution or a cure. If he finds one, the problem is resolved. If he does not, he lives in the hope that doctors will eventually provide it.
He pays the price of that hope. He gives his time, his attention, his money and his trust. He accepts that the system may not have cured him yet, but he believes it still can. Belief itself becomes a currency he spends.
But once he moves from doctor to doctor and nothing changes, something quiet and final happens inside him. He grows weary of the entire medical system. He stops paying its price. He no longer argues with the diagnosis, compares prescriptions or reads the pamphlets in the waiting room. He has concluded that the system itself is not where his cure lies.
After that loss of hope, he will do one of two things: live with the disease until he dies, or seek an entirely different medical system. The choice between these two is rarely made rationally. It is made out of exhaustion.
In society, surrendering to the disease rarely happens because alternatives, whether better or worse, are abundant. Someone will always claim to have the answer: the herbalist, the preacher or the stranger with a sufficiently loud voice.
The question is never whether an alternative will appear. The question is which one the suffering person will accept when his guard has fallen.
The issue in Somalia in 2026 is that people have been moving from government to government, from president to president, searching for hope. Each new face carried its own promise.
Each promise depended on the belief left behind by the one before it. Today, that belief is fading. Hope in the entire system has been profoundly weakened.
The willingness to visit another doctor, the equivalent of participating intellectually and psychologically in Somalia’s political transitions, is disappearing. It is not that Somalis will necessarily refuse to vote if a ballot reaches them. It is that many may no longer invest themselves emotionally in the outcome.
The deeper participation, the hoping, the arguing and the belief that this leader will be different, has diminished. For many, it no longer matters who gets elected. The ceremony may continue, but the audience has stopped watching. The system itself is losing its capacity to inspire hope.
Today, the issue is not simply the suffering. It is not only political suffering, security suffering or economic suffering. These hardships have existed for decades. Somalis have survived worse. What is different now is the posture of the patient.
The patient has turned his face toward the wall.
The issue is the loss of hope in the entire political system built since the Embagathi peace process to provide solutions to Somalia’s problems.
A system that has lost the capacity to give hope is not simply inefficient. It is dangerous for the country.
Somalia today offers fertile ground for anyone who whispers promises of an alternative. Reasonable people may still weigh the costs and benefits of such promises against reality, measuring what is offered against what they already know. But others, exhausted by prolonged suffering, may simply accept them.
There is no guarantee that masses of people will always make rational choices. They may even accept destruction when it is presented as the cure for a disease that has caused too much pain.
Pain narrows the mind. Prolonged pain narrows it further. A person who has been bleeding long enough may stop asking the one holding the knife whether he is a surgeon.
This is the trap created by the collapse of hope.
A system that can still deliver, even imperfectly, can absorb the energy of those seeking alternatives. A system that cannot deliver releases that energy, and the energy must go somewhere.
It flows toward whoever appears with a sufficiently loud voice and a sufficiently convincing story to make suffering seem as though it has a name and a culprit.
At that point, prolonged frustration may make some people more receptive to alternatives they would otherwise have questioned.
This is where the reasonable person finds himself.
Related articles
The absence of a sensible alternative that he can pursue places him in a corner. He has few doors through which to escape, and each carries a cost greater than he can easily bear. None promises success. All demand sacrifices from him and from those around him.
He can invent an alternative.
But inventing an alternative means entering a struggle on several fronts: against those who benefit from the existing system, against those competing for the same political space, and against the inertia of a population too exhausted to believe that his promise will differ from the last.
He must build almost from nothing, without established institutional support, and his efforts will be tested immediately. The cost is not only what he personally pays. It is also what his followers pay, and what those who might have followed him but chose otherwise may eventually bear.
He can also conclude that peaceful means are unlikely to succeed and are increasingly limited.
If so, he may begin questioning the effectiveness of peaceful solutions, although resorting to force would carry enormous risks for the country and future generations.
Whether such methods would produce the cure he seeks is another question, one that cannot be answered in advance. The price is paid first; the outcome becomes clear only afterward, to those who survive to witness it.
Or he can endure the consequences of a poor alternative accepted by an exhausted population.
A society that has lost hope in its institutions may become willing to follow whoever extends a hand of assistance, even a quack selling poison as medicine.
He may find himself watching what he could not prevent.
That, too, is a cost, perhaps the highest of all: to see the country he understands being led toward an outcome he had already feared.
For Somalia’s youth today, these dilemmas translate into four choices. None is easy, and none comes without sacrifice.
The first is to leave the country and endure ghurba, the pain of exile: to live in safety while one’s homeland suffers; to build a life that one’s children may inherit in a language their grandparents do not speak; to send money home and hope it reaches someone who still believes in something; and to miss funerals and weddings that cannot be attended in person.
The second is to bear the cost of inventing a solution: to stay, to work and to establish whatever small institution one has the strength to build, knowing that the effort may take a lifetime and that its rewards may not arrive within one’s own lifetime.
The third is to surrender to the disease until the nafs, the inner self, is lost: to stop expecting anything from the country and, eventually, from oneself; to drift through years that demand little because little has been invested in them.
The fourth is to wait and watch the alternative that may emerge.
If it proves good, al-hamdu lillah, praise be to God.
If it proves worse, the remaining years may be spent trying to change it.
—-
Musharaf Abdullahi Rashid is a Somali researcher and postgraduate student at the Doha Institute for Graduate Studies in Qatar.
The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the editorial position of Dawan Africa.