Loading article content...
Loading article content...
“A town belongs to everyone who lives there; its administration should reflect their voices, abilities, needs and shared aspirations equally.” Hussein Shegow Mohamed
Spend a few days in Hudur and listen to conversations about who governs the town, who occupies public offices, who commands checkpoints and who serves in the security forces. A recurring concern emerges: the influence of the baadiyo, the rural villages, grazing areas and settlements surrounding the town.
I want to be clear about what this article is and is not. It is not an attack on rural people. Many are my relatives, neighbours and friends, and the baadiyo has always been the backbone of Somali society. Nor is it an accusation against any particular official.
Rather, it examines a pattern that some Hudur residents discuss privately: the perception that people with rural backgrounds and networks dominate the administration, while those born and raised in the town remain underrepresented.
A town administration is more than a collection of offices. It is the face of government for ordinary citizens. Who occupies those offices, and how they are appointed, shapes how residents experience public authority.
The phrase “from the governor to the lowest-ranking soldier” reflects how some residents describe the extent of rural influence across Hudur’s administration.
In their view, this influence extends from senior officials and department heads to district officers, security commanders and rank-and-file personnel.
How did this situation develop?
Following years of conflict, state-building in South West Somalia relied heavily on armed mobilisation and clan-based support. Those capable of mobilising fighters, maintaining security or commanding community loyalty acquired considerable political influence.
Over time, such relationships may have shaped appointments and recruitment, giving established networks an advantage over applicants without similar connections.
These arrangements may have been understandable during periods of insecurity. But practices developed under emergency conditions should not necessarily become permanent features of governance.
When appointments are concentrated within closely connected social networks, decisions and opportunities can circulate among the same individuals.
This can make an administration appear closed to outsiders, blur the distinction between public responsibility and personal obligation, and weaken residents’ sense of ownership.
An official who owes an appointment to a relative, political patron or clan elder may face pressure to prioritise personal relationships over the public interest.
It would be unfair, however, to suggest that officials from rural backgrounds are necessarily unqualified or acting in bad faith. Many are hardworking, courageous and committed to stability. Some have made considerable sacrifices for the region.
The issue is not where individuals come from, but whether the system provides fair opportunities for everyone qualified to serve.
Consider the young men and women born and raised in Hudur. Many attended local schools and madrasas, acquired diplomas or university degrees, and gained experience through humanitarian organisations, businesses and community initiatives.
They know the town, understand its challenges and have skills that could benefit its administration.
Yet many young residents believe they have limited opportunities to participate in senior administration, security leadership and local decision-making.
Some remain unemployed. Others drive bajaaj, operate small businesses or leave for Mogadishu, Nairobi, the Gulf or Europe in search of opportunities.
This represents a potential double loss. Hudur loses valuable skills and energy, while its young people lose opportunities to contribute to their hometown.
A town that cannot offer educated youth meaningful roles in public life risks creating frustration and disengagement.
Based on my observations and conversations, several barriers appear to discourage greater participation by Hudur’s urban-born youth.
The first is limited political and clan-based backing. Where influence depends heavily on established networks or the ability to mobilise supporters, young professionals may struggle to compete.
The second is access to decision-makers. When vacancies are not openly advertised or recruitment procedures are unclear, qualified applicants without influential connections may never receive consideration.
The third is financial pressure. Political participation often involves expenses that many young people cannot afford.
Finally, there is discouragement. When young people repeatedly see opportunities distributed through personal connections, some stop applying or participating altogether.
That withdrawal is particularly damaging because it deprives the community of individuals who might otherwise contribute to meaningful change.
Clan balance remains an important reality in Somali politics. It has played a role in political arrangements since the collapse of the central state.
The problem arises when clan considerations become the overriding basis for appointments, leaving insufficient room for competence, accountability and broader community representation.
Hudur is home to families with different histories and connections to the surrounding countryside. Its administration should reflect that diversity.
Related articles
The central question should not simply be which clan an official belongs to, but whether the administration fairly represents and serves the town’s residents.
When appointments are perceived as favouring established networks, public confidence can weaken, particularly if residents believe that services and development priorities do not adequately reflect their needs.
A troubling distance appears to exist between some young residents and Hudur’s political leadership.
Young people frequently express concerns about limited consultation and insufficient opportunities to influence decisions affecting their future.
Some describe feeling like guests in their own town.
Officials, meanwhile, may regard young critics as inexperienced or unfamiliar with the responsibilities of governance.
Both perceptions can deepen when meaningful dialogue is absent.
Educated and engaged young people should be viewed as an opportunity rather than a threat. Excluding them risks strengthening resentment and weakening confidence in public institutions.
This brings us to the central question: who gets to govern Hudur?
If political appointments continue to depend primarily on established clan alliances and historical security relationships, we must ask whether such arrangements can meet the town’s changing needs.
Governance cannot remain indefinitely tied to the political logic of emergency. It must increasingly be measured by competence, fairness and accountability.
Inclusion means allowing people from rural and urban communities, women and men, and younger and older generations to participate meaningfully.
Opportunity means opening public positions to individuals with the qualifications and commitment to serve.
Accountability means ensuring that officials answer to residents and that citizens can raise concerns without fear.
These principles are consistent with Somali traditions of consultation, fairness and collective decision-making.
Several practical measures could help strengthen Hudur’s administration and rebuild public confidence.
First, introduce transparent recruitment. Vacancies in the civil service, local administration and, where appropriate, security institutions should be publicly advertised with clear selection criteria.
Second, strengthen youth representation. Youth advisory structures or designated opportunities for young professionals could provide meaningful access to decision-making and leadership experience.
Third, establish regular dialogue. The governor and senior officials should meet students, young professionals and community representatives to discuss local priorities and report on progress.
Fourth, invest in professional training. Internships, mentoring and partnerships with educational and development organisations could prepare young graduates for public administration and leadership roles.
Fifth, broaden the understanding of representation. Clan balance and local inclusion need not compete. A representative administration can respect community realities while recognising the abilities and aspirations of all residents.
Finally, I appeal to those holding public office today. Communities that supported the administration during difficult times deserve recognition. But the next stage of governance requires a wider circle of participation.
Open the doors, share responsibility and give Hudur’s young people meaningful opportunities to serve.
Their education, experience and attachment to the town should be treated as valuable public assets, not overlooked because they lack established political connections.
Hudur belongs to everyone who lives in it, whether their roots are in the town or the surrounding countryside.
The sooner its administration reflects that shared ownership, the stronger its prospects for inclusive governance, lasting peace and stability.
—-
Hussein Shegow Mohamed is a writer focusing on Somali politics, security and humanitarian affairs. He holds a master’s degree in international relations and diplomacy.
The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the editorial position of Dawan Africa.